• JUser::_load: Unable to load user with id: 79
Wednesday, February 10, 2010

Buffett takes on chokepoint in Chicago with BNSF

Written by 

Warren Buffett and Bill Gates face a roadblock on the route toward payoff on their investment in U.S. freight transportation, Bloomberg reports. Chicago, whose railroads made it hog butcher for the world a century ago, is a tangle of bottlenecks where a quarter of the nation's rail freight stalls while trying to navigate the city.

"We can't keep running trains from Los Angeles to Chicago in 55 hours and then take 36 hours to get a rail car from one side of Chicago to the next," said Matt Rose, chief executive officer of BNSF. "We either need to fix Chicago or avoid it."

For Buffett, 79, a solution could help overcome skepticism about his $26-billion bid for BNSF, which shareholders are to vote on tomorrow. For the Chicago area, speedier passage could head off a loss of rail traffic, jobs and tax revenue when the city is coping with a drop in trade-show business.

Part of the answer may come from Calpers. The California Public Employees' Retirement System is backing two and possibly three rail yards outside Chicago to handle intermodal freight. The yards would help reduce the typical day-and-a-half slog across the city's intersecting Amtrak, commuter train and freight tracks, helping railroads in their quest to take more shipping from the trucking industry.

The first is a $1-billion BNSF yard that opened in 2002. Calpers's real estate unit, CenterPoint Properties Trust, is scheduled to open a $2-billion Union Pacific facility nearby in September. Negotiations are under way with Canadian National Railway Co. for a third yard, said Michael Mullen, CenterPoint's chief executive.

The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation is one of Montreal- based Canadian National's 10 biggest shareholders, with 1.8 percent of the stock, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. Michael Larson of Cascade Investment LLC in Kirkland, Washington, investment manager for Gates, 54, didn't return calls seeking comment. Amy Enright, a spokeswoman for the foundation, referred calls to Larson.

A train ride through BNSF's new yard caught Buffett's attention, Rose said. He briefed the Berkshire Hathaway Inc. chairman on the rail connections to the West Coast and on a surrounding network of distribution centers in April 2008, a year after Buffett first invested in Burlington.

"He loved it," said Rose, 50. Nineteen months later, Buffett offered to buy the rest of the Fort Worth, Texas-based company. Buffett didn't respond to a request for comment e- mailed to his assistant Carrie Kizer.

Buffett was impressed by how the facility works with big retailers such as Wal-Mart Stores Inc., Rose said. Bentonville, Ark.-based Wal-Mart owns a distribution center half a mile away to receive goods arriving from Asia. Being so close to the yard slashes shipping costs: Retailers spend about $2,000 to send each container from Shanghai to Joliet, Illinois, then $25 more to reach nearby distribution facilities, Mullen said. The additional cost would shoot to $200 a container for a facility five miles away, he said.

What Buffett called his "all-in wager" on the U.S. economy's future prompted Standard & Poor's to strip Berkshire of its last AAA credit rating. Oil prices in the $70 to $80 range favor railroads over long-haul trucking as an investment, said Eric Marshall, research director of Dallas-based Hodges Capital Management. Berkshire's Class A shares have gained 15 percent to $111,700 since Nov. 2, the day before the Burlington deal was announced.

"All the railroads will do well because they're the low- cost provider of transportation," said Marshall, whose firm sold 500,000 BNSF shares after Buffett's offer and used the proceeds to acquire 556,000 shares in Kansas City Southern. "When oil was at $20 a barrel, that was not the case."

Kansas City Southern is installing new intermodal technology to connect Chicago and other U.S. cities with Mexico, Marshall said. Its shares have risen 26 percent to $30.33 since Nov. 2.

Success in railroads now hinges on which companies best take advantage of intermodal shipments, which produce more revenue per carload than other freight. Donald Broughton, a St. Louis-based analyst for Avondale Partners LLC, has a "buy" rating on Union Pacific because it's winning intermodal freight from BNSF.

By the end of 2009, BNSF's weekly lead over Union Pacific in intermodal container shipments had dwindled to 11,355 from 32,500 in late 2008, Broughton said in a report.

Union Pacific is likely to capture even more business from BNSF, Broughton said, when its intermodal yard opens in September about 40 miles southwest of Chicago in Joliet. Union Pacific shares have gained 12 percent in the wake of the BNSF agreement, while Canadian National's have gained 2.4 percent.

Buffett's investment in Burlington opens doors for the entire railroad industry on Wall Street and in Washington, Rose said.

"It's a vote of confidence that railroads can provide significant value to the capital markets and great social value," he said.

After the recession ends, population growth and economic expansion will spur U.S. freight shipments to rise at a compounded annual rate of 2.2 percent for the next decade, and intermodal traffic to increase 3.6 percent per year, estimated Charles Clowdis, an IHS Global Insight analyst in Lexington, Massachusetts.

The new intermodal freight yards near Chicago will digest some of this growth, said Hani Mahmassani, director of Northwestern University's Transportation Center, in Evanston, Illinois, which studies global transportation systems. But they're not big enough to shift large volumes of traffic out of the central city, so they won't solve all its rail traffic problems, he said.

Losing its role as the nation's premier rail hub would harm the regional economy for generations, said Jeffery Sriver, director of rail infrastructure at the Chicago Department of Transportation. Chicago faces growing competition from new intermodal switching yards planned or built by BNSF near Kansas City and by Canadian National in Memphis, Tenn.

The railroads helped Chicago become a center for slaughterhouses, mail-order retail and steelmaking. In the process, Chicago developed expertise that allows it to compete as a global city today, said Saskia Sassen, a Columbia University sociologist.

"New York does finance," Sassen said. "Chicago has legal, financial and transportation skills that are rooted in the material practice of making things."

Calpers bought CenterPoint, an Oak Brook, Ill.-based real estate investment trust, for $3.4 billion in 2006. Starting in 2001, CenterPoint purchased 6,000 acres of land on an abandoned U.S. Army arsenal in Joliet. The core of the BNSF yard is a set of parallel tracks where four trains, each 1.5 miles long, are loaded and unloaded simultaneously. Workers need 10 hours to unload trains onto tractor- trailers -- half as much time as a decade ago -- for companies such as Wal-Mart, which uses global positioning satellites to track each container, dispatching truck drivers via e-mail as trains approach.

Such improvements grew out of a crisis. After winter storms snarled traffic in 1999, Chicago Mayor Richard Daley formed a coalition of six freight railroads, plus city and state officials and Amtrak. The group wants to fix 78 local bottlenecks at a cost of $2.5 billion, according to its Web site. The coalition has secured $761 million so far, about a quarter from railroads and the rest from government.

It has applied for $300 million of the $1.5 billion in rail infrastructure grants President Barack Obama's administration will award later this month. The group also is seeking $700 million from a transportation bill pending in Congress.

When Obama announced $8 billion in high-speed rail grants Jan. 28, he included $133 million for a new overpass near 63rd Street and Interstate Highway 94 on Chicago's south side. Each day, the overpass will allow 82 passenger trains and 46 freight trains to pass by at different levels, instead of having to take turns for a clear track.

Federal Railroad Administrator Joseph Szabo called Chicago infrastructure the most significant freight bottleneck in the U.S.

"You don't achieve much traveling 110 miles an hour in a cornfield if you can't get into the city," Szabo told reporters last month. "Chicago has to get fixed."

Get the latest rail news

The inside scoop from RT&S, IRJ and Railway Age on and off the track. Join our email list.